Crazy Aaron's Better Butter - Extra Buttery Smooth and Creamy Putty

September 24, 2025

When you buy through links on this site, I may earn a commission.

Somewhere in between regular stiff putty and gooey slime, there's this cool new Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty. While it may look like butter, this extra buttery smooth, soft, and creamy yellow putty is quite inedible. Like traditional putties, you can stretch it, bounce it, tear it, twist it, squeeze it, and punch it, but now it just feels more squishy, melty, and oddly satisfying in hand... or when slicing with a butter knife. It's made in the USA, never dries out, and is perfect for relieving boredom, reducing stress, helping to focus, fidgeting, shaping into a stick of butter, or just giving as a cool stocking stuffer gift. Again, please do not eat butter putty, but it is non-toxic just in case. 🧈

Find It
Videos
Tags

►Vat19.com

►Amazon.com

Related Tags

Click One To Discover Even More Cool New Stuff!

Popular Today

▼ Show All ▼

Latest Cool New Stuff

▼ Show All ▼

Related Stuff: Toys and Games

LEGO Dried Flower Centerpiece

This rustic LEGO building set for adults is a large 812 piece model of a colorful dried flower centerpiece for the dining table.

Ant Farm Revolution

360 degree ant habitat filled with transparent gel that allows you to watch an army of ants create tunnels and has an LED light that projects shadows of giant... Read On

Anti-Monopoly Board Game - Free Enterprise Versus Monopoly

In this altered modern version, you can choose whether you want to play as a free-market competitor or a monopolist and then must adhere to entirely different... Read On

SKLZ Shoot-Around - Basketball Return Chute

An innovative basketball return chute that attaches to the rim and lets you practice free throws, three point shots and other shots from around the court endlessly... Read On

World's Largest Pac-Man Arcade Game... Includes Galaga!

This version of Pac-Man blows up the mazes, dots, ghosts, fruit, and power pellets to mega-sized proportions on a massive, super bright 108 inch LED screen.

Atari 2600 My Play Smartwatch - Plays Classic Games and Tracks Fitness

This smartwatch tells the time, tracks your fitness, and includes 4 playable Atari 2600 games: Centipede, Missile Command, Pong, and Super Breakout. That's it!

NERF M41A Pulse Blaster from ALIENS

This cool new, year 2179-inspired NERF LMTD M41-A Blaster is the NERF blaster version of the Colonial Marine's standard issue Pulse Rifle from the movie ALIENS.... Read On

Jonti-Craft Giant Tub Tower with 32 Storage Bins

A space-saving, mobile wooden storage tower that holds up to 32 bins that can hold toys, art supplies, craft supplies, office supplies, or anything you wish.

Aqua Jump Eclipse - Gigantic 20 Foot Floating Water Trampoline

This gigantic inflatable floating water trampoline has a 20 foot wide diameter with 124 square feet of jumping surface.

▼ View All Toys and Games ▼

Related Stuff: Stress Relief

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter - Extra Buttery Smooth and Creamy Putty

Electronic Bubble Wrap Keychain

This unique keychain has 8 rubber buttons that look and feel exactly like the bubbles on bubble wrap. When you press a bubble, the keychain makes that ever-satisfying... Read On

Crazy Aaron's Angry Putty Stress Ball - The Putty That Fights Back!

Putty designed to get stronger and more resistant the more you squeeze, stretch, tear, bounce, fold, twist, and play around with it. It actually fights back!

SpaCapsule - Dry Water Jet Massager And Sensory Soother

SpaCapsule is a self-contained, full body massage system, aroma-therapy unit, audio and video entertainment system packaged into one futuristic capsule-shaped... Read On

Bubble Wrap Suit - Hooded Jacket and Pants Made from Real Bubble Wrap!

This suit is made entirely from genuine working bubble wrap and is inspired by the space suits worn by Zoltan's UFO cultists in the movie, Dude, Where's My Car?

Horriball - Disgusting Squishy Stress Ball

When your victim gives this seemingly innocent stress ball a squeeze, clear bubbles filled with flies, rats, worms, or cockroaches covered in a bloody-looking... Read On

Poppit Sheets - Bubble Wrap Popping Sheets For Stress Relief

Like a box of tissues, this box of bubble wrap sheets is there to supply you with one of the most satisfying ways to relieve stress... popping bubble wrap.

Aromasteam - Full Body Portable Steam Sauna

This full body portable steam sauna easily sets up anywhere in only 10 minutes for a relaxing spa-quality experience in your own home!

Giant Stress Ball

Overcome with stress, frustration, aggravation, anxiety, boredom, or you accidentally watched or read the news? Then you're gonna need this Giant Stress Ball.

NeeDoh Nice Cube - Firm With a Hard Squish / Soft With a Gentle Squish

This ice cube-shaped stress ball is filled with goo that feels firm when squished hard and soft when squished gently for an oddly satisfying squish sensation.

▼ View All Stress Relief ▼

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter - Extra Buttery Smooth and Creamy Putty