Crazy Aaron's Better Butter - Extra Buttery Smooth and Creamy Putty

September 24, 2025

When you buy through links on this site, I may earn a commission.

Somewhere in between regular stiff putty and gooey slime, there's this cool new Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty. While it may look like butter, this extra buttery smooth, soft, and creamy yellow putty is quite inedible. Like traditional putties, you can stretch it, bounce it, tear it, twist it, squeeze it, and punch it, but now it just feels more squishy, melty, and oddly satisfying in hand... or when slicing with a butter knife. It's made in the USA, never dries out, and is perfect for relieving boredom, reducing stress, helping to focus, fidgeting, shaping into a stick of butter, or just giving as a cool stocking stuffer gift. Again, please do not eat butter putty, but it is non-toxic just in case. 🧈

Find It
Videos
Tags

►Vat19.com

►Amazon.com

Related Tags

Click One To Discover Even More Cool New Stuff!

Popular Today

▼ Show All ▼

Latest Cool New Stuff

▼ Show All ▼

Related Stuff: Toys and Games

Topics For The Table Napkins

Unlike regular napkins that aren't fun whatsoever, these napkins fold into an origami handheld game loaded with questions and facts to help you and your dinner... Read On

TinyTV 2 - Miniature Fully Functional Retro Television

This ultra-small portable television has a digital screen housed inside a classic 1960's analog television cabinet and holds up to 10 hours of video footage.

Back To The Future Desktop Hoverboard

This miniature working version of Marty McFly's iconic levitating hoverboard is made from pyrolytic graphite that hovers naturally over a slightly curved base... Read On

Kyosho Space Ball - Remote Control 360-Degree Flying Sphere

a remote controlled 360-degree flying sphere with a safety frame around it to absorb impacts, crashes, and malevolent cat attacks

Retro Nintendo NES Cartridge Drink Coasters

These 8-bit inspired, double-sided drink coasters look just like classic Nintendo NES Cartridges that many of us remember fondly.

Pinch Me - Coffee Scented Therapy Dough

This unique therapy dough isn't for baking, but you can knead it, stretch it, pull it, mold it, pinch it, smoosh it, and even throw it during times of stress,... Read On

Mindflex Game - Telekinetic Obstacle Course

High tech game lets you move a small ball up and down around an obstacle course using nothing but the power of your mind!

Sportcraft Anywhere - Portable Ping Pong Set

This compact and portable table tennis kit lets you play ping-pong on nearly any table. No massively invasive ping pong table required!

Star Trek U.S.S. Enterprise Flying Disc

Just grasp the disc AKA saucer section of the U.S.S. Enterprise and throw it to a friend or dog like you would any other flying disc and the rest of the foam-made... Read On

▼ View All Toys and Games ▼

Related Stuff: Stress Relief

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter - Extra Buttery Smooth and Creamy Putty

Crazy Aaron's Angry Putty Stress Ball - The Putty That Fights Back!

Putty designed to get stronger and more resistant the more you squeeze, stretch, tear, bounce, fold, twist, and play around with it. It actually fights back!

Electronic Bubble Wrap Keychain

This unique keychain has 8 rubber buttons that look and feel exactly like the bubbles on bubble wrap. When you press a bubble, the keychain makes that ever-satisfying... Read On

Bubble Wrap Suit - Hooded Jacket and Pants Made from Real Bubble Wrap!

This suit is made entirely from genuine working bubble wrap and is inspired by the space suits worn by Zoltan's UFO cultists in the movie, Dude, Where's My Car?

Bingsu Ringz - Crunchy Ring-Shaped Stress Ball

This unique, ring-shaped stress ball is filled with water and crunchy, iridescent Bingsu beads, named after Bingsoo the popular Korean shaved ice treat.

Endless Banana Peel Keychain

If you love that satisfying tactile sensation of peeling a banana, now you can do it over and over again without having to eat a ton of them with this cool new... Read On

Mars Zen Garden

Transport your frazzled, anxiety-ridden, stressed-out Earthbound mind to the tranquil surface of Mars when you mindlessly mess around with this Mars Zen Garden.

Infinite Beer Can

Recreate the sensation of opening a can of beer or soda, over and over again!

Zen Garden Grow Kit

Are you feeling stressed out, anxiety-ridden, worried, nervous, or even frazzled? Then seek serenity and inner peace while tending to this Zen Garden Grow Kit.